APR vs APY: Why Banks Quote One and Not the Other

APR is what borrowing costs. APY is what saving earns. APY counts compounding and APR does not - which is exactly why banks quote APY on savings, where it makes the number bigger, and APR on loans, where leaving it out makes the number smaller. Both are legal. Neither is an accident.

The two numbers side by side

APRAPY
Full nameAnnual Percentage RateAnnual Percentage Yield
Used forLoans, cards, mortgagesSavings, CDs
Counts compounding?NoYes
Counts fees?Most loan fees, yesNot applicable
EffectMakes the cost look smallerShows the true yield

The pattern is easy to remember: each product is quoted with the number that flatters it.

Savings adverts use APY, because compounding makes it bigger. Loan paperwork uses APR, because leaving compounding out makes it smaller.

Both are standard, legal figures. You just need to know which one you are looking at.

Converting between them

APY = (1 + APR ÷ n)n − 1

Here n is how many times a year it compounds. On a 5% APR:

CompoundsnWorks out at
Once a year15.000%
Monthly125.116%
Daily3655.127%

The gaps look tiny at 5%. They stop looking tiny at card rates.

Where it costs you real money

A card advertising 24% APR compounds daily. Run the same conversion and it works out at 27.11% over a year on a balance you carry.

On $5,000 that is the difference between $1,200 and $1,355 of interest in a year - about $155 the smaller label quietly leaves out. Across several years of carrying a balance, the choice of label is worth real money to the lender.

It also explains something useful: paying part-way through the month helps. Because interest is worked out daily, every day your balance is lower reduces that month’s charge. You do not have to wait for the statement date.

Comparing savings accounts

On the savings side APY is the honest number - it is what you actually earn if you leave the money alone for a year.

Two rules cover it:

  1. Compare on APY alone. How often it compounds is already inside the figure. A 4.6% APY beats a 4.5% APY, whatever the compounding schedules say.
  2. Put APY into projections. The compound interest and savings goal calculators expect the APY your bank quotes. No conversion needed.

Why loan APR includes fees

Loan APR includes most fees you must pay - origination, points, some closing costs - which is why it comes out higher than the bare interest rate on the same loan.

That is what makes it the right number for comparing offers. A low rate with heavy fees can be worse than a higher rate with none, and only the APR shows it. This is exactly the trap in the personal loan guide, where a 12% loan with a 5% fee really costs 14.78%.

The rule in one line

Borrowing? Compare APRs. Saving? Compare APYs. Never mix them.

What the gaps are worth

On savings, $10,000 left alone for ten years:

On borrowing, $12,000 over three years:

Same debt, same three years, $2,806 apart. That gap is the whole argument for moving high-rate card balances onto something cheaper.

Common questions about compound interest

What is the difference between APR and APY?

APR is a yearly rate that does not count compounding, and it is used for loans, where it does include most fees. APY does count compounding and is used for savings. A 5% APR compounded monthly works out at 5.116% APY.

How do I convert APR to APY?

Take one plus the APR divided by the number of compounding periods, raise it to that number of periods, and subtract one. For 5% compounded monthly that gives 5.116%.

Why is my credit card interest higher than the APR suggests?

Card interest compounds daily, so a 24% APR behaves like 27.11% over a year if you carry a balance. On $5,000 that is $1,355 rather than $1,200 - about $155 the label leaves out.

Which number should I compare?

Loans against loans using APR, because it includes most fees. Savings against savings using APY, because it includes compounding. Never compare one against the other - they are measuring different things.

Why does loan APR include fees?

So you can compare offers fairly. A low rate with big fees can work out worse than a higher rate with none, and the APR is what shows that. It is the most useful single number when two loan offers differ.